8 Of The Best Shaving Creams For Safety Razors

There is always an option available when it comes to choosing the best shaving cream for safety razors; you just need to look for it in the right place! And here you are at the right place!

Particularly, if we are to talk about our beards (or head), We men fall into two different categories- some of us just don’t mind staying shaggy, and the others like it clean and shiny. 

Likewise, if you are the dude who doesn’t bother growing facial hair, you probably would have tried out different shaving creams!

Well, each shaving product would seem promising, but you should take caution when you are picking out shaving cream; we know men are into the art of shaving! 

The Best Shaving Cream For Safety Razors

As I said earlier, when it comes to having a smooth shave, you’ve got two options: either go for shaving creams or soaps. Yes, both require different techniques while using (you see - I’ve already discussed that previously).

We'll get into the soaps, but the creams shouldn't be overlooked. They are not as cool or nostalgic as a good badger hairbrush and a metal tin, but they work exceptionally well. 

Creams (for that matter) come with different options; you can buy one that's easier on your skin. 

Like, do you need a cream with a good scent? One that isn’t hard on your sensitive skin? One has the natural ingredients written on its bottle? OR all rolled into one?

Don’t get worked up. I know we men are not picky all the time, but when it comes to shaving, we just are!

Yeah!

Men prefer creams that are just suitable for their face (or head), and that's why there are quite a few shaving products in the market you can try out.

With creams, all you need to do is just have some dab on your hand and apply to create a lather you desire!  

Worth a try, isn’t it?

Let's take a look and find out what type of shaving cream is best for you.


Cremo Shaving Cream

Sale
Cremo Barber Grade Original Shave Cream,...
  • Impossibly slick formula fights nicks, irritation and razor burn

Why choose Cremo?

I know shaving doesn’t always mean “apply, shave, rinse,” Right? 

Good lord if it were that easy - I am talking about the razor burn that happens during the shave. It truly is a discomfort- talk about the itchiness along with the red bumps on the skin (ahh, the annoyance, I can feel - I can feel ya!). 

So if you are someone who shaves frequently, you might have gone through this. 

Now, what is the key, you may ask? Cremo is the way to go! 

What Does it Contain?

This shaving cream is comprehended with a rich formula containing the slickest molecules, especially for a close shave. Especially made to give you a smooth - shave without having to worry about the razor burns, aye!

Where would we be without cremo? Shaving our faces with mud and berries, I suppose. This is probably one of the slickest creams you can buy on the market.

You don't need to use a lot, and a dime-sized dollop will go a long way.

Talk About The Scents

Cremo comes in a couple of different scents; you can have a smooth shave, not to mention the fragrance if you're into that sort of thing. Cremo comes with different scents:  Classic, Cooling, Sage & Citrus, Sandalwood, Silver Water & Birch, Unscented. 

So, buy the one that best suits your mood. Also, the bottle says that it will last 90 days. I've never found that to be particularly true, though it's not an expensive cream.

Less Lather Doesn’t Mean Low Quality

The cream doesn’t generate the thickest lather; however, its premium quality lubricants just bridge the gap. 

It excellently protects your skin from irritations, razor burns, cuts, and nicks. 

But here's the catch- less lather can be a good thing for those who use a cartridge or disposable razors, as the cream won’t stuff up the blades. Also, Cremo can be best used with double edge blade razors.

Building Blocks

It's made in the USA from macadamia seed oil, aloe, calendula extract, lemon extract, papaya extract, and olive leaf extract. That's an impressive list of ingredients.

“America. Hell Yeah!”

Pros

  • Too slick to worry about razor burns.
  • Made up of natural ingredients good for the skin.
  • No skin irritations, nicks, or cuts.
  • Works with almost any type of blade.
  • It can be applied with bare hands.

Cons

  • Some have complained it feels like “an oil lotion” when applied to the face.
  • Can clog the razor.

Taylor Of Bond Street

Sale
Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream...
  • Cream helps prepare your beard for shaving and moisturizes your face

 We, men, get curious while picking out between shaving creams, so many questions pop up in our heads. Ultimately  the concluding one is always this - “What type of shaving cream is best for men?” That's how the cookies crumble.

Well, let me enlighten you in this regard (I told ya - I am here to save your day!). 

Because on our second spot comes the Taylor of Old Bond St Sandalwood Shaving Cream. Yeah! the old bond street! One of the best shaving creams for both beginners and experts. *drum rolls in background, please*


Popular shave creams Among Most Men

This England-made Taylor of Old Bond Sandalwood shaving cream is used widely by men for a reason. That quality shave you can have with this one will leave you in awe!

When applied, the cream helps soften the hair for a close shave. With a lather as rich as this one, it is easy for almost anyone to have a good shave. A bad shave is out of the question here. 

The cream is the key for serious shaves; the buying range is vast - from newbies to intermediate shavers.

The best thing about Taylor of Old Bond Street is that it comes with its own plastic bowl! Yep, lathering made easy, if you don’t want everything on your hands just make use of the shaving bowl it has.

Plus, the cream leaves your face moisturized! Wow!

A Sweet Scent

This is another one of the best creams that also comes in a unique couple of scents with top notes of amber, rosemary,  vetiver, patchouli, and sandalwood. 

I personally recommend Taylor of Old Bond Street because I think it's the best shaving cream for a safety razor. It can be lathered up with just your hand and water, or you can lather it up with a badger brush and a bowl.

The Components

Taylor of Old Bond Street cream has an awe-inspiring list of ingredients; even the words are too natural to pronounce! 

It has Aqua (Water), Stearic Acid, Myristic Acid, Potassium Hydroxide, Coconut Fatty Acid, Glycerin, and probably even more! 

And for a touch of fragrance, this one of the best shaving cream contains Linalool, Geraniol, Benzyl Salicylate, Citronellol, Eugenol, Benzyl Benzoate, Benzyl Cinnamate, Evernia Furfuracea Extract, Evernia prunastri Extract. 

A flavourful list, isn't it?

Pros

  • Easily made rich lather for a smooth shave.
  • Pleasant for all types of skin.
  • Contains natural ingredients.
  • Leaves your face moisturized.

Cons

  • A little on the expensive side.
  • Scent can be strong for some.
Proraso Shaving Cream
Proraso Shaving Cream for Men, Refreshing and...
  • Soften skin for a close shave without irritation

It wouldn't be a party for shaving creams for safety razors if it didn't involve at least one Proraso product… or two. Yes! This is something one should have in their spa

Proraso shaving creams have a lot to answer.  

What is the best shaving cream for sensitive skin?

Let me tell you this - Proraso shaving cream has to be the finest shaving cream for sensitive skin one can look for. 

Why? Let's chew out some facts.

For almost a century, Proraso has been into the shaving game; thanks to its affordable price and higher quality, we can have a comfortable shave. 

However, the lather may not seem so luxurious, but it still provides a decent lather that helps soften the beard hair for a closer and comfortable shave. Yet, it's the best one you can have at that price!

Back to the point, if you have skin that is hypersensitive and can easily be affected, this shaving cream is for you - as it works exceptionally well! 

As Proraso shaving creams come in a variety of styles for more delicate skin and also with included moisturizer, which if you've read [The Proper Way To Shave], you understand how important that is.

This is a very low lather cream that won't gunk up your razor, which is very important when picking a shaving cream for a safety razor.

 

Pros

  • Cheaper than its competitors
  • Gives you a closer and comfortable shave
  • Doesn't cause any irritations

Cons

  • Doesn't generate the thickest lather but is totally workable.
  • Its scent is not preferred by everyone.


The Best Shaving Foam For Safety Razors

To the Foams! Shaving creams aren’t always necessary for shaving; you have the alternatives like a foam to try out and let me tell you this, it doesn’t hurt to adapt to a change. (good for you)


Why should you need Foam for shaving?


Men, let’s talk about facts. I know we are always late for something in the worst way possible. Imagine waking up and realizing you are late for something important, and you need your facial hair clean ASAP!

You’ve got no time; you rush to the bathroom, you look for shaving cream, you dab, create lather and see if it’s made right. Tell you what, you are late already!

Let us cut to the chase; a shaving foam could’ve saved you for sure. No ifs and no buts about it, foam is one of the easiest and quickest ways to get your shave done. 

Shaving foams are easy to apply. They provide you “not so heavy but thick lather” to get you through. Also, they are easy to wash off because of their less stickiness than other shaving mediums.

Sooner to later, you just need a good foam that gets your face looking like Santa on a snowy night. If that's you, then these might be some of the best shaving cream options for safety razors.

 

Gillette - Sensitive Shave Gel


Sale
Edge Sensitive Skin Shave Gel for Men, Protects...
  • Contains aloe and is formulated to be non irritating on sensitive skin

Finest for Delicate Skin

This shaving gel can be reassuring if you have hypersensitive skin, just as written on its bottle. Hence, you no longer have to get annoyed by other products that leave your face burning after a shave. 

Edge is particularly designed for skins that are sensitive; you can have a close shave without having to worry about irritations or razor burns. 

Plus, it leaves your face cool - Now that’s some silver lining right there!

The shave gel contains ingredients that are easier on your skin, and while using this gel, the razor blade glides over your skin while the cooling conditioners freshen up your face.

It is made sure you are given the exceptional smoothy shave!

I've said it once, and I'll say it again. Gillette may charge, what I think is, an arm and a leg and a toe for their blades, but this best shave gel is the bee's knees. It gives a very rich lather, and it's relatively inexpensive. The smell is great as well - in fact, it smells like divine. You only need a dab of it to go a long way.

This is a great option if you just like the feel of a traditional foamy lather.

Pros

  • Has cooling conditioners that leave your face feeling refreshed.
  • Provides excellent razor glide.
  • Best for sensitive skin.

Cons

  • Somewhat expensive.

Barbasol

The Legacy    

Who wouldn’t like to try out a shaving cream for men that has been used for nearly 100 years now? With improvements along the way (of course). 

This Old-school product has been on almost every veteran man’s face from 19s till date. Sure, the history reflects Barbasol's awesomeness.

Easy to Use

Barbasol is a natural-ingredients-packed cream that can be used with both single and double-edged razor blades, the best thing is that you don’t have to worry about any cuts as the thick creamy lather protects your skin while you can have the best shave. 

Grab the bottle, shake it, hold it upright, hold down the top to release the lather. 

And finally, have a dab on your hand and apply it to your face, trust me, while you shave, the razor glides just perfectly over your skin. (all because of the thick lather)

Multiple Options

Like we’ve talked about before, how the other creams have their different variants. The old-school Barbasol also comes in different kinds, there are the ones that are good for delicate skin (Barbasol sensitive skin shaving cream), the ones with a really good scent (Barbasol Pacific Rush) and I am pretty sure there are plenty more. 

And each of them contains natural ingredients in them which are Just good on your face. (so sure about this)

So, Suit yourself and get the one you need!

What else needs to be said about this shaving cream?

Barbasol, Barbasol, Barbasol.

Classic.

It can’t go wrong.

Enough Said.

Pros

  • Extra thick lather
  • Protects your skin while you shave
  • Has natural components good for your face.
  • Easy to apply

Cons

  • Some have complained it creates a little too much lather. Must have focus while shaving.

The Best Shaving Soaps For Safety Razors

Let’s advance to the SOAPS! No, I am not talking about the bath soaps; obviously, you would have known that by now. 

Shaving Soaps! 

Let’s talk about these bad boys and how they differ from shaving creams, what is shared between them and what are the best ones out there, yadda yadda yadda.


Old But Gold


The shaving soaps, every pro knows about them and how these products are even used today. Obviously, as everything kept advancing, soaps did too. The product might be traditional, but the improvements throughout history are exceptional.

Well, the idea is pretty much the same as I told you in the beginning. You use them to create a lovely lather and have a close and comfortable - best shave! 

But there's a catch! Why do we go different ways when considering a shaving product? You know it -yes, do what’s best for you! 

Simple as that. 


Are Soaps Better than Most Creams?


Men prefer shaving soaps because nostalgia is always good to feel, but there’s more to it: Soaps don’t usually let you down compared to creams; the chances of having razor burns and skin irritations come way down (if you are using the right soap). 


For the most part, shaving soaps are made with added fat from animal or plant sources. These ingredients help create a safety layer of lubrication on your skin to prevent any loss of hydration. On the other hand, some creams are stuffed with unnatural and unnecessary ingredients that could cause a razor burn, nicks, irritations, and can even lead to skin problems, you get the picture.


You Need More Than Just a Shave Soap

The process of using a shave soap can be a bit lengthier than the creams; you also need to have some additional tools on the shelf. The soaps are generally what you'll commonly see paired with a safety razor.

They don't typically have a distracting lather, but you will need a badger hair brush to get a shave soap going. You might also want to invest in a shaving bowl as well.

All right, you have the idea, and by now, I am pretty sure you know what you would prefer. 

Now, Let’s discuss some of the best soaps in the market. And when I say some of the best, I mean it.

 

Proraso - Soap In a Bowl

Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin,...
  • It is designed for those who prefer the traditional method of using a shaving brush

Like I've said before, it wouldn't be a party without Proraso. This is wet-shavers mainly go-to soap with exceptional results. The soap offers all the same benefits and options as their cream (maybe a little more), but it comes conveniently in its own bowl.

You simply pop the top open, add your water and stir with your shave brush. This is probably the most common shaving cream for safety razors that you'll see because you don't need to buy an additional bowl to mix your lather in.

Originated in Italy, this - one of the best shaving products - gives you an ultra-creamy lather that helps moisten your skin and hair before the shave. The formula is uniquely made to cause no redness or itchiness, which men with easily affected skin usually face after the shave.

Yep, this soap is also ideal for sensitive skin. 

It is used in the traditional way of using soaps (if you know, you know). Annnndd, Grab your brush and bowl and get ready for a quality shave!

It also comes in different scents, if you're into that sort of thing.

Pros

  • Comes with its own bowl
  • Generates a great lather protective to your skin
  • 91% of natural ingredients used
  • Relatively cheaper than other products

Cons

  • The smells like - the scent doesn’t seem to suit everyone
  • Higher chances to get fungus/mold if not sealed properly.

Himalaya Shaving Soap

Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap with Shea...
  • American Made Shaving Soap easily creates rich lather: it lubricates razor for a slick, cushioned...

I'm not sure if people that live in the Himalayas shave with shaving soaps, but this product would lead me to believe they do. Because this shaving product is made from 100% all-natural ingredients with no added scents, it is marketed as able to be used by both women and men. 

While I surely haven't tested this product on women's skin, I wouldn't doubt it by how silky smooth it feels when you lather it up.

Ladies and gentlemen, wouldn’t it be a heck of a product that can be used by both men and women? There you have it! 

Henry Cavendish Himalaya -is exceptional and creates a rich, creamy lather that softens your hair for a close and comfortable shave. But there’s more to it!

The other great hit about this is that it doesn’t contain any artificial color or fragrance, just natural origin ingredients used like soy extract, which gives your skin a smooth and softer feel. 

Way to go, ladies!

But hey ladies (lads too), there’s more! 

The soap contains Shea Butter that leaves your skin moisturized (not oily). That said, worrying about skin irritations or dryness while using this is out of the question! 

You don’t have to worry about the lather drying out before you even get to it, like the case with most of the best shaving creams, foams, gels, soaps. Yet, it would be best to spend more time on shaving with this one. You know, to make sure you are getting the best shave possible. On fleek!

You will definitely need to buy a bowl and a badger shaving brush with this one, but if you enjoy the idea of a 100% natural soap, this is right up your alley.

Pros

  • It can be used by both men and women.
  • Leaves your skin silky smooth and moisturized after the shave
  • No artificial color or fragrance used
  • No skin irritations with this one

Cons

  • Does not lather well (spend more time into it)

Colonel Conk

Col. Conk Bay Rum Shaving Soap 3.75 Ounce Large
  • Special large edition of Colonel Conk's famous soap

Why does Colonel not have an ‘R’, but it sounds as though it should? This is a glycerine style of soap, so it is going to lather very easily and has the added benefit of having multiple scents. I think some people like the idea of soap that looks and feels like it if that makes sense.

All too often, the shaving cream for safety razors has more of a pasty or chalky feel to it. If you're the type of gentleman that likes the idea of a puck style bar of soap, then this is definitely an option that you need to get into.

Key Features

Colonel Conk, also written as Col. Conk, has been in the shaving game for more than 150 years. 

This has to be the oldest one on our list so far; it is best known for its shaving soaps. 

With this old-school player, you can generate a rich n’ thick lather, which gives this traditional scent of tropical bay tree leaves and Jamaican rum. Sweet!

Similarly, skin irritation or razor burn isn’t a thing to be worried about. As I told you earlier, “some of the best” you remember, right?

Col. Conk contains avocado oil and vitamin E, which leaves your skin fresh and moisturized after a shave. Again not oily! WOW!

Grab Your Tools

As you already know, the traditional art of shaving, there isn’t much to it though. You just oughta wet it, swirl a shaving brush around to make bubbles, then apply and shave.

 Also, the razor glide is unbeatable. I am amped to try this one out!

Pros

  • Creates a creamy-rich lather
  • Unmatched razor glide
  • More affordable than the range of shaving soaps
  • Has a sweet scent
  • A veteran in the game

Cons

  • Sometimes the foam becomes flimsy.

Is it better to shave with shaving cream or soap?

Picking out between traditional shaving cream and soap can sometimes bite!

Both of them are supposed to do the same thing, right? Well, yes. But how these shaving products work is quite different. 

How so? Let's find out:

Undoubtedly,  good quality or traditional shaving creams will carry natural ingredients that are good on your skin. And when I am talking about the shaving creams, I don’t mean the tin foam one can get from a drug store.

Ahh! That stuff really messes up your skin, causing dryness, skin irritation, which can even be the reason for long-term skin problems like premature aging and acne from clogged pores. 

If you are currently using one, do yourself a favor and switch! 

Besides, for quality shaving, you can add some additional natural ingredients in your shaving creams like Lanolin, Natural Silicons, and Hydrolyzed Oat Protein.  

So hey, why not give your skin a good therapy while shaving with a higher quality shaving cream? Hang around as we have gathered some of the high-quality shaving creams for you and will be discussing them all right here in a moment!

Now, what about the guys who are comfortable with wet-shaving?

Never you mind, Wet shavers! I’ve got your back- Shavings soaps come to the rescue since they are usually used for wet shaving, primarily by experienced wet shavers.

If you are using shaving soap, it’d undoubtedly take some time (more than the cream) to create the lather you fancy.

But it’ll be worth it, as you can even add extra ingredients into the soap before using it. Also, you need to have more than just soap to start off, having a shave brush and a bowl doesn’t hurt, right?

Soap or Cream?

Upfront, let me tell you which one is easier and doesn’t require any astrionics- yes, shaving cream! 

It is much easier than the soap; just some dab on your hand, apply it to your face and create the lather you prefer for a good shave. There you go, King.

On another note, if you are an experienced gent and are confident in your art of shaving. 

You can surely stick to the soap, although it requires a somewhat harder recipe and more tools. Trust me, it's totally worth it!

Confused? Don’t be - I am here to save your day!

Now, when I think of shaving creams for a safety razor, I want something that is going to provide a decent lather, but not so much that you can't really see what you're doing.

This is especially important when working with a straight edge safety razor, as you can be prone to cutting yourself if you have to apply extra pressure to move away from all the additional lather.

Although, it is not a secret that we (men) often face terrible outcomes after a shave. Lord! The skin irritation, nicks, razor burns, and cuts. The list just goes on! Let me tell you this, you have unique skin as every man does, and it needs good care.

Sometimes we don’t bother to think much over this, but it is almost necessary to keep shaving issues distinct and in mind.

Here’s what you can do: first off, stop using the product that’s been causing you trouble shaving. Second: look for their descriptions when switching. If you often get irritations, chances are you have sensitive skin (like me).

I know very well, God, it is like torture when using a product not suitable for your sensitive skin.

Back to the numbers, third: buy the one that is the best fit for you and your skin! There are tons of shaving creams/foams/gels/soaps made for your unique skin.

You aren’t just looking closely. Don’t sweat it; you are at the right place!

With that being said, here are some of the best shaving creams, soaps, foams, gels for safety razors options that give you quite a bit of room to work with.

Summary

If you were around until this last piece, you should’ve found the one product - the best safety razor - shave cream - that you always needed! (I know - I know - I just saved your day *wink*). 

These were some of the best shaving creams products in the market. Suit yourself, my man! 

Get the one that gives you the confidence to stand out; there are plenty of them! 

More or less, If you are someone who always wants to have a quick shave, shaving creams should be your priority, or if you are a wet-shaver that does not mind going steady with your beard (or head), go for the shaving soaps! 

Or you can even try both on different occasions. Fire dude! 

Last update on 2022-04-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Related Posts

Best Product To Straighten Hair
Best Hair Removal Cream for Private Parts
Best Haircut for Receding Hairline